Thursday, December 27, 2007

This Again

One of the most tired and unimaginative criticisms of ‘alt comics’ is the following: desperate for validation by the literary elite, cartoonists create boring stories about the uninteresting problems of average people so that The New Yorker and their ilk will reassure them that they are worthy. This argument presumes an intimate knowledge of the cartoonists’ psyches that the critic never has; and those who make this argument are rarely good readers of the comic that’s right in front of them, so how can we put much faith in their analysis of a human being? Most artists would like to be appreciated by smart readers, but to reduce the many motivations that drive them to a single, overwhelming need to be loved by the ‘tastemakers’ shows a real lack of depth or suggests that The Critic is posing (“He’s too smart to really believe that, right?”). Why is he upset that others create comics that he doesn’t like? I assume that artists are trying to make a comic that they believe is good, interesting, funny, moving, or truthful, etc, even when I think it stinks.

Then The Critic will direct his attention to the reader, psychoanalyzing him by making (surprise!) the same argument. This reader, the critic says, thinks that “if the elitists like the comics I like, then I can feel good about myself and the comics I read; respectability, long sought, will finally be mine.” (I have never met anyone like this . . .) So, if you make or like a comic the critic doesn’t like, it must be because you are deeply insecure: he can see no other reason and can’t imagine that other people think differently than he does or like different kinds of stories. Why, though, does this critic constantly return to the issue of validation?

Comics in general have not achieved the status of, say, the novel, but the debate about acceptance is really on its way to being over, a fact that makes these complaints a waste of time, and a bit foolish. Comics by ‘alt-cartoonists’ in particular are being reviewed and printed in mainstream periodicals; their books are being published by major publishing houses, being made into films, and being read in more and more high school and college courses . . .

A cartoonist whose work I sometimes like and whose political essays I usually agree with makes some of these complaints here. Not only does Rall rehash these arguments and offer confident claims about cartoonists’ and readers’ sex lives, but he shows himself to be a shaky reader by the unfounded assumptions and misrepresentations he makes; for example, he calls woman in Ware’s strip a “spinster,” an often derogatory term almost never applied to anyone as young as this main character. Here’s another one: “Daniel Clowes' "Mister Wonderful" treads standard art-comics territory: unattractive boy meets dowdy girl.” It matters a great deal that these main characters are not a boy and girl, but two middle-aged adults with decades of relationship trouble behind them, a history that two teenagers simply could never have. Clearly Rall is trying to be cute here, but he intentionally misrepresents the age of the characters in Clowes’s and Ware’s comics to make them appear to be something they aren’t. If after reading a review/essay, you come away with a completely mistaken impression of what the comic is about, you know the writer is not to be trusted . . . . Is he afraid that if he describes them accurately, they might actually sound appealing?

“I don't know why anyone cares about what other people read,” Rall asks. It’s a good question, one he should ask of himself . . .

7 comments:

Rick said...

I took “unattractive boy meets dowdy girl” to be a play on “boy meets girl”. As in “boy meets girl/boy loses girl/boy gets girl” kind of story. I didn’t infer from Ted Rall’s piece that the two characters were young, but instead that the story employed the same old romantic love relationship plot device, only with a geeky nerd feel.

K. Parille said...

Rick,

I think its Rall's MO to mischaracterize stories that he doesn't like; I suppose you can use "boy meets girl" to refer to adults - though that usage seems unususal to me. Why not say "man meets woman?" And the fact that he was shifty with the age of another character makes him seem disengenuos to me. And given that so much of what happens in Clowes's story does not happen in the typical "boy meets girl" story, why use that term . . .?

gg said...

Nike air force sale store.
air force 1 high sale online sale!
air force 1 low sale online sale!
air force 1 high womens online sale!
Nike air force livestrong online sale!


cheap air force ones shoes for sale.
air force 1 high sale online sale!
air force 1 low sale online sale!
air force 1 high womens online sale!
Nike air force livestrong online sale!



Nike air force 1 sale online sale!
air force 1 cheap online sale!
air force 1 livestrong online sale!
cheap air force 1 low online sale!
womens air force 1 online sale!

Anonymous said...

I'm surecheap D3 items its Rall's MO to Cheap GW2 Gold mischaracterize stories that she isn't going to such as; Perhaps you should use Diablo III Gold"boy matches girl" to consult people ( space ) nevertheless incheap D3 Gold which application would seem unususal in my opinion. Why not state "man matches person?

Anonymous said...

Kräuterkunde und wow gold Alchemie sind sehr nützlich für Raids und sehr gut für die WoW Gold und mehr, die Sie erstellen und alle Ihre überschüssigen Matten können für einen guten Gewinn im Auktionshaus verkauft werden.Für Warriors sind Bergbau und Schmiedekunst die beste Wahl für Stufenanstieg. Darüber hinaus sind Juwelenschleifen, Verzauberkunst und Engineering alle nützlich Warriors. Als Juweliersymbolen, könnte man Handwerk einzigartige Edelsteine für ebay wow gold einige schwerwiegende stat Verbesserungen. Und bezaubernde erlauben es, Verzauberungen auf Schilde, Waffen und Rüstungen hinzufügen. Motes und Primals sind nur mit der Veröffentlichung von The Burning Crusade Expansion geschaffen und werden als Arten von Materialien von erheblichem Wert eingestuft. Feuer und Luft holen die meisten aber als sie das härteste fördert sind zu sammeln, mit jedem Ur-Verkauf für 30 Gold im Auktionshaus.Mit einem Wort, Drehen Motes in Primals, und dann verkaufen sie, wow gold telefonrechnung können Sie eine große Anzahl von wow gold.

fgdg said...

You laugh at me for being different, but I laugh at you for being the same LOTRO Gold, the consequences of today are determined by the actions of the past Lord Of The Rings Gold, to change your future,LOTRO Gold alter your decisions today.


I know someone in the world is waiting for me, although I've no idea of who he is. But I feel happy every day for this Buy Xbox Live Points, If a woman is not sexy, she needs emotion; if she is not emotional, she needs reason Cheap Minecraft Gift Code, in this world, only those men who really feel happy can give women happiness Ultimate Game Card.

ali khan said...

I went over this internet site and I believe you have a lot of fantastic information, bookmarked Your Site...Best advertising Agency in the world | top advertising agencies in pakistan | Marketing Agency