Thursday, May 20, 2010

Clowes, Wilson, and Drama

The most obvious antecedent to the episodic structure of Wilson is the daily comic strip and its familiar "a few panels of setup followed by a panel with a punch line" format. But another influence, one that can account for some of what makes Wilson so strange, is the theater. Clowes has said he conceived of his previous comic, Mister Wonderful, as a "two-man play." This gave him a chance to play dramatist by trimming down his approach: in much of the story, two characters just sit and talk. In a recent interview, Clowes noted that theater was again on his mind as he worked on Wilson, a "one-man play" that develops theatrical conceits in ways that reveal some profound ambiguities of narrative practices present within comics.

Mister Wonderful used an expansive archive of comic techniques -- speech balloons, thought balloons, interior monologue boxes, fantasy scenes, flashbacks, and unusual formal approaches -- to give us access to Marshall’s thoughts and feelings:

But Wilson strips away nearly all of these devices, featuring only the present-tense image overlaid with the word balloon:

But "word balloon" isn’t quite right. Convention has taught us (or perhaps deceived us) that what appears within a word balloon is spoken. At a recent talk on Clowes’s book tour, an audience member asked if Wilson was speaking or thinking the text that appears in the balloons. "That’s a really good question," Clowes replied; "I’m not sure."

In Wilson, the balloon (it’s not quite right to call it a speech balloon when referring to Clowes’s work) has no single function -- sometimes it implies spoken text, other times thoughts, and elsewhere its meaning can’t be fixed: “I’m not sure.” Clowes is rarely schematic with these things. Just because a type of balloon functions a certain way in one strip doesn’t mean it works the same way (or needs to be interpreted the same way) in another.

Here’s where the dramatic conventions come in: In the traditional theatrical soliloquy a character speaks to no one. But a soliloquy is often interpreted as if it’s unspoken, as if it embodies the uncensored and most truthful thoughts of the character (Wilson is uncensored -- hostile to others and himself, for example -- in a way that most people are only in their heads). It is spoken, of course, because that’s the way to deliver thoughts on the stage. The book’s second strip (and many others) fit neatly into the soliloquy mode:

On this kind of page, Wilson, essentially alone on stage, speaks-thinks to himself; the balloon signifies speech and/or thoughts. But the soliloquy has another strange aspect. Even when other actors occupy the stage near the soliloquist, tradition suggests they simply do not hear him -- they act as if he isn’t talking (because in a way he’s not) or as if he isn’t there. Many of Wilson’s single-page "blackout gags" take this approach: he says awful (and awfully funny) things to people, yet his speech gets no reaction from them. In the vaudeville blackout gag, the theater’s lights are cut off immediately after the joke. There’s no reaction from other characters, only from the audience. And this often happens in Wilson: Clowes cuts the scene right after his hero speaks. The last two panels of "The Money":

A sense of Wilson as documenting ‘Wilson alone on stage’ is reinforced by his many phone conversations. He talks, but we never once hear the words of his interlocutors:

Throughout the comic, so much of the action is off-stage or off-page: these are the same thing in Wilson. Other characters begin to feel like props in the main character’s psychodrama -- they don't have quite the same "ontological" status as he does.

A few strips replicate the visual perspective of being in a theater: the static position of an audience member watching a play. The characters are drawn at the same size in each panel and are fully visible:


(Clowes discuses the above strip here.) There are no filmic shifts of perspective implying a moving camera or a mobile viewer; the scene is unedited, as it would be in a playhouse. And the panel border becomes an analogue for the proscenium arch, creating a frame that houses the actors and scenery -- the entirety of the fictional world available to the viewer.

--------------------------------------------
When I first wrote about Wilson a few weeks ago, I mentioned that one way to think about the strip was as a “dramatic monologue,” a poetic form connected to theatrical conventions. This discussion of the form may offer some ideas that can be applied to Wilson. . .

Also: Here's an odd "reaction shot"; perhaps the "inscrutable" Pippi's response to the always antagonistic Wilson appears as the image on the screen:

34 comments:

Anonymous said...

Totally off topic - but couldn't help but notice a Stuart Hample influence in that 'Kramer's' strip you posted (couldn't afford the book!). Do you know much about him - I was a big fan of his Woody Allen strip years ago.

Tim Hensley said...

Hello, Anonymous,
Listen to an interview with Stuart Hample here:
http://inkstuds.com/?p=2522
for more info...

Anonymous said...

Thanks! Your own stuff has been a very rewarding 'find' for this jaded comic reader! Excellent blog too - especially when you're unlocking that 'mystery' (the key to any great narrative) in Clowes.

Matthew_Haskett said...

Something, perhaps subconscious, caused Clowes to draw what we would call "word balloons." In this act, perhaps Clowes demonstrated that Wilson is actually speaking--he just might not be consciously aware of it now! Either way, in the end, I think it definitely is a decision to make by each reader.

Anonymous said...

Ken, I'm really enjoying your writing on Wilson. Most of the reviews of it on the internet haven't dug very deep but I found your description of the dialogue as a kind of theatrical "soliloquy" very interesting. I also thought of it being like following a 'gonzo-style' piece of investigative writing but with the reporter as a visible protagonist - if that makes any sense...
Anyway, looking forward to any more writing you may do on the book.

Ken Parille said...

Oben,

Thanks -- I'm not sure if I will write more on Wilson, though there is a lot more to say . . .

viagra online said...

I thought of it being like following a 'gonzo-style' piece of investigative writing but with the reporter as a visible protagonist.

viagra online said...

Nice comic despite it's horrible drawing stile, do you have more of this underrated jewel.

Wartrol Reviews said...

All I am New, I have been looking around this board for about a few hours as a guest. I found it extremely and it has helped out allot. I hope to hang around for abit and contribute.

buy viagra online said...

Hello,
This is an awesome blog post. Its very informative blog post... Thanks a lot for the share.... Keep posting... Thanks!

Acai Berry Select Reviews said...

Thanks for sharing this article! Its interesting and I am always searching for informative information like this.. Thanks a Lot again..

The Diet Solution Program said...

Hi, great article. The way you explained it is really awesome and makes every one to read till the end. keep posting..

posicionamiento web said...

Well, I do not actually imagine it is likely to have success.

Seo Services Company said...

i truthfully enjoy your own writing kind, very remarkable,
don’t give up as well as keep writing due to the fact that it simply just worth to follow it.
looking forward to see a whole lot more of your current well written articles, enjoy your day

generic pharmacy said...

Good sence of humor,,That was something I never read before thanks for sharing,,

Canadian internet pharmacy

Logo Design Company said...

It's good to read this information from your post. You have an interesting way of drawing people in. Keep up the good works..

Buy Generic Viagra said...

Even when other actors occupy the stage near the soliloquist, tradition suggests they simply do not hear him-- they act as if he isn’t talking, Throughout the comic, so much of the action is off-stage or off-page: these are the same thing in Wilson.

Link Building Service said...

I thought of it being like following a 'gonzo-style' piece of investigative writing but with the reporter as a visible protagonist.

shakeology reviews said...

Good stuff! Thanks for not being afraid to share your opinion - i will be back soon to and will keep following your blog!

WOW Gold EU said...

Thank you for giving me such a good chance, let me be able to read this essay so good of a son, thank you very much.

Over the years withgames has been constantly striving to maintain high quality of ingame services in various of MMORPGs such as Gold WOW, Cheap Tera Gold, Warhammer, Age of Conan, EVE, FFXI, GW, MS and so forth, with four years of experience of providing MMORPGs online services, Uraion is more than prepared to offer ultimate Buy World Of Warcraft Gold, aion powerleveling, aion accounts and more.

Tom Riddle said...

Nice article, keep sharing.

Custom logo design

Professional Logo Design said...

Nice comic, I really enjoyed reading it.

Led Flashlight review said...

Thanks for posting! I really enjoyed the report. I've already bookmark this article.

downtown Cincinnati hotels said...

This is a great post. no doubt a great article. Thanks for discussing the facts.

PSD To Wordpress said...

Excellent post. I want to thank you for this informative read. Keep up your great work.

Facebook and Twitter Marketing business power said...

Thank you for another great article. Where else could anyone get that kind of information in such a perfect way of writing? I have a presentation next week, and I am on the look for such information

Cheap Logo said...

Thanks for sharing your website.This blogs are very informative. I really say thanks to you.

Anonymous said...

Something, quiteBuy RS Gold possibly subconscious, created Clowes to draw what we would phone "word balloons." through this act, quite possibly Clowes demonstrated that Wilson is really speaking--he just might not be consciously conscious of it now! both way, within WOW Goldthe end, I contemplate it surely may be considered a choice to produce by every one reader.

Unknown said...

This topic is pretty good and the writer's views are unique and not so hard to understand.I like it very much, and by the way I want to share some interesting and very useful websites to you:www.rsorder.com! Iam sure you can find out funny things there.

runescape gold

rs gold

cheap rs gold

buy runescape gold

lolgames said...

as it would be in a playhouse. And the panel border becomes an analogue for the proscenium arch, creating a frame that houses the actors and scenery
Cheap League of Legends Account

Buy LOL Coaching

Unknown said...

into perspective what you let to wait trine age ago the Chiefs and as well line of work partners. conjointly, they viewpoint educate, much Division‑I schools. and so you only try it for 24 hours earliest. threw rating passes of 13 contests for future unfixed agents. former illustrious picks: Sutton, Cheap nhl Jerseys win this nonliving race and it becomes combined because teams incertitude Wilkerson’s power; it’s the Patriots do go-to-meeting and she nigh e’er outstrip. I’ll ne’er blank out, said defending organiser for the place. He was 7-for-7 for 145 yards and a top 10 to wit. Nate pedagogue, Titans annotation: Trendy sleeper, https://adamfantacy.tumblr.com/

Unknown said...

Hi there! This article couldn�t be written much better! Looking through this post reminds me of my previous roommate! He always kept talking about this. I most certainly will forward this post to him. Fairly certain he’ll have a good read. I appreciate you for sharing! My Blog http://xerobuff.weebly.com/

Unknown said...

Simply desire to say your article is as amazing. The clarity in your post is just great and i could assume you’re an expert on this subject. Fine with your permission allow me to grab your feed to keep up to date with forthcoming post. Thanks a million and please carry on the enjoyable work. My Blog http://subscene.pen.io/

Unknown said...

If they are, then it's seemingly that their firm is rising. Subsequently, this host needs to be a safe choose. If they are not hiring, then they're most likely really struggling. My Blog http://www.facecool.com/profiles/blogs/the-studio-will-sell-the-vehicle-as-a-premium-battle